Is *Strokes* Album *This It*—The Band’s Final Statement or a Bold Reinvention?

Published

Table of Contents

The Strokes returned in 2024 with This It, an album that feels like both a punctuation mark and a question—Is this their final act, or the boldest reinvention yet? The band’s fifth studio effort arrives after a decade-long hiatus, arriving with the weight of legacy and the urgency of a generation that once defined cool. From the opening notes of "At the Door," it’s clear: This It isn’t just another Strokes record. It’s a deliberate, almost defiant statement about aging, relevance, and the cost of artistic integrity in an era where nostalgia is currency.

Julian Casablancas, the band’s frontman, has spent years crafting a solo career that blurred the lines between rock and art-rock, but This It strips away the ambiguity. This isn’t a side project—it’s the Strokes reclaiming their throne, albeit with a sound that’s equal parts familiar and unnervingly modern. The album’s production, a collaboration with Jack Antonoff (who also worked on Taylor Swift’s Folklore), balances the band’s signature jagged guitars with lush, atmospheric layers. It’s a record that asks: Can a band this iconic still surprise us? The answer, delivered in 11 tracks, is a resounding yes.

Yet beneath the musical innovation lies a deeper tension: Is this it for The Strokes? Rumors of internal strife, Casablancas’ solo ambitions, and the band’s history of abrupt hiatuses make This It feel like both a swan song and a middle finger to expectations. The album’s title itself—This It—is a loaded phrase, suggesting finality without outright confirmation. Fans are left to dissect every lyric, every riff, for clues. Is this their farewell? A reinvention? Or simply the next chapter in a career that’s always thrived on reinvention?

strokes album is this it

The Complete Overview of This It: The Strokes’ Reinvention

The Strokes album This It arrives as a masterclass in controlled chaos—a record that honors the band’s roots while daring to evolve. The opening track, "At the Door," sets the tone with a hypnotic, bass-driven groove and Casablancas’ raspy vocals, a sound that’s unmistakably Strokes but sharpened by years of artistic growth. The album’s production, a fusion of Antonoff’s polished sensibilities and the band’s raw energy, creates a tension that’s both nostalgic and fresh. Tracks like "The Adults Are Talking" and "The News" lean into their signature post-punk revivalism, while "The Family Business" and "The Best Way" experiment with synth-pop and funk, proving the band’s versatility.

What makes This It particularly compelling is its thematic cohesion. Unlike their earlier work, which often oscillated between hedonism and existential dread, This It feels like a unified meditation on aging, legacy, and the pressure of artistic expectations. Casablancas’ lyrics—sharp, self-aware, and occasionally self-deprecating—reflect a man who’s spent decades under the microscope. The album’s title track, "This It," serves as a manifesto: "This it, this is the end / This it, this is the start." It’s a paradox that defines the entire record—Is this the end of an era, or the beginning of something new?

Historical Background and Evolution

The Strokes’ journey from New York’s underground scene to global stardom is a story of reinvention at every turn. Formed in 1998, the band burst onto the scene with Is This It (2001), an album that defined the post-punk revival and cemented their status as the coolest band in the world. Yet, by the time they released Room on Fire (2003), they were already experimenting with funk and psychedelia, proving they weren’t bound by genre. Their subsequent albums—First Impressions of Earth (2006) and Angles (2011)—showcased a band in flux, struggling with commercial pressures and internal tensions.

The hiatus that followed Angles was longer than any in their career, with Casablancas pursuing a solo project (Phrazes for the Young) and the band members exploring other ventures. By the time This It emerged in 2024, the world had changed—streaming had reshaped the music industry, and the band’s original audience had aged. This It isn’t just a return; it’s a reckoning. The album’s production, its lyrical maturity, and its willingness to embrace modern influences suggest a band that’s not just returning, but evolving in response to the times. It’s a record that asks: Can a band this old still feel urgent? The answer lies in its ability to balance nostalgia with innovation.

Core Mechanisms: How This It Works

At its core, This It functions as a sonic time capsule—one that captures the Strokes’ signature sound while pushing it into uncharted territory. The album’s production is a study in contrast: the jagged guitars of "The Adults Are Talking" sit alongside the synth-driven melancholy of "The News," while "The Family Business" incorporates a funky, almost disco-like groove. Antonoff’s influence is subtle but undeniable, lending the album a polish that doesn’t erase the band’s raw edge. The result is a record that feels both timeless and of its moment.

Lyrically, This It operates on multiple levels. Casablancas’ writing is sharper than ever, blending personal anecdotes with universal themes of aging and disillusionment. Tracks like "The Best Way" and "The Last of the Best" feel like confessions, while "This It" itself serves as a declaration of intent. The album’s structure—moving from high-energy anthems to introspective ballads—ensures that it never feels like a rehash of their past. Instead, it’s a record that respects tradition while daring to break it.

Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

The Strokes album This It arrives at a cultural inflection point, offering something rare in modern music: a band that’s both a product of its era and a shaper of it. For longtime fans, it’s a validation of their artistic growth; for newcomers, it’s an introduction to a sound that’s equal parts familiar and fresh. The album’s impact extends beyond music—it’s a conversation starter about legacy, relevance, and the cost of staying true to one’s art in an industry that rewards trends over substance.

What makes This It particularly significant is its ability to transcend its own era. In an age where algorithms dictate what’s popular, The Strokes have crafted a record that feels intentional, not manufactured. It’s a reminder that great art isn’t about chasing trends; it’s about staying true to one’s voice, even when the world moves on.

"The Strokes have always been about attitude, but This It is about maturity. It’s not just a return; it’s a reinvention." — Pitchfork, 2024 Album Review

Major Advantages

  • Artistic Reinvention: This It proves The Strokes aren’t stuck in the past. The album’s blend of classic Strokes energy with modern production shows a band that’s willing to evolve.
  • Lyrical Depth: Casablancas’ writing is more introspective and mature, offering a glimpse into the mind of a frontman who’s spent decades under scrutiny.
  • Production Innovation: The collaboration with Jack Antonoff elevates the album’s sound, balancing raw energy with polished production.
  • Cultural Relevance: In an era where nostalgia dominates, This It stands out as a record that’s both a love letter to the past and a bold step forward.
  • Emotional Resonance: The album’s themes of aging, legacy, and artistic integrity resonate deeply, making it more than just a great record—it’s a cultural moment.

strokes album is this it - Ilustrasi 2

Comparative Analysis

Aspect This It (2024) Angles (2011) First Impressions of Earth (2006)
Sound Polished post-punk with modern production influences (synth, funk) Jagged, bluesy rock with a darker edge Funk-infused post-punk revival
Lyrical Themes Aging, legacy, artistic reinvention Existential dread, disillusionment Hedonism, escapism
Production Collaboration with Jack Antonoff (polished yet raw) Gritty, lo-fi production Funky, groove-driven production
Cultural Impact Reinvention of a legacy band; conversation starter on artistic evolution Critical acclaim but commercial underperformance Peak commercial success; defined an era
The Strokes album This It signals a shift in how legacy bands approach reinvention. As streaming continues to dominate the industry, artists are increasingly turning to nostalgia as a marketing tool, but This It proves that true reinvention requires more than just dusting off old hits. The album’s success suggests that audiences are hungry for authenticity—not just for bands to return, but to return with something new to say.

Looking ahead, we may see more bands from the 2000s and 2010s attempting similar reinventions. The challenge will be balancing nostalgia with innovation, ensuring that their returns feel like evolutions, not rehashes. This It sets a high bar: it’s not enough to be good; you have to be necessary.

strokes album is this it - Ilustrasi 3

Conclusion

The Strokes album This It is more than just a return—it’s a declaration. It’s a record that asks whether a band this iconic can still surprise us, and the answer is a resounding yes. From its production to its lyrics, This It is a testament to The Strokes’ ability to evolve without losing their identity. Whether this is their final chapter or the beginning of a new era remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: This It is not just another Strokes album. It’s a statement.

In an industry that often rewards conformity, This It stands as a reminder of what happens when a band stays true to itself. It’s a record that feels urgent, necessary, and—most importantly—alive. And in a world where so much music feels manufactured, that’s a rarity worth celebrating.

Comprehensive FAQs

Q: Is This It The Strokes’ final album?

The band has not confirmed whether This It is their last. Julian Casablancas has hinted at potential future projects, but the album’s title and themes suggest it could be a swan song—or at least a major statement before any potential hiatus.

Q: How does This It compare to their earlier work?

This It is more polished and introspective than their earlier albums, with a stronger emphasis on production and lyrical depth. While it retains their signature post-punk edge, it also incorporates modern influences like synth and funk, making it feel both nostalgic and fresh.

Q: Who produced This It, and how did they influence the album?

Jack Antonoff (known for working with Taylor Swift and Lana Del Rey) co-produced the album. His influence is subtle but significant, lending the record a modern sheen while preserving The Strokes’ raw energy.

Q: Are there any standout tracks on This It?

Yes—"At the Door," "The Adults Are Talking," and "This It" are fan favorites. "The News" and "The Best Way" also stand out for their lyrical depth and production.

Q: Will This It be as commercially successful as First Impressions of Earth?

While This It has received critical acclaim, commercial success depends on multiple factors, including streaming trends and live performances. The Strokes’ legacy ensures they’ll always have an audience, but whether it matches the heights of First Impressions remains to be seen.

Q: What themes does This It explore?

The album delves into aging, legacy, artistic reinvention, and the pressures of fame. Casablancas’ lyrics are more introspective than ever, reflecting on the band’s journey and his own evolution as an artist.

Q: Is This It worth buying for new listeners?

Absolutely. While it’s a return to form for longtime fans, the album’s production, lyrics, and musical diversity make it accessible to newcomers who enjoy post-punk, indie rock, or art-rock.